In Yoga philosophy, there are four major paths available for
spiritual progress: Karma, Bhakti, Jnana and Kriya. Bhakti Yoga proceeds
through control and channelization of emotions. Karma Yoga proceeds through
unselfish service of society. Jnana Yoga proceeds through intellectual
discrimination between real and unreal, usually accompanied with a deep study
of the scriptures. And Kriya Yoga proceeds through refinement of the gross and
subtle energies. Each of these four paths is said to be capable of taking the
spiritual aspirant to the highest state of enlightenment. However, it is not
possible for a human being to follow only one of these four and exclude all
others. Human existence is a mixture of all these aspects and thus, a good
combination of these paths is required, somewhat like a cocktail. The primary
difficulty here is that there is no simple formula available, which can help us
in deciding which combination to follow. Pursuing the path of Yoga is a bit
like consuming alcohol. It tastes bitter in the beginning, but then slowly one
starts appreciating its deep flavours. And mindless over-consumption of both
results in severe problems! But just to avoid misconceptions, please note that
consumption of alcohol is generally not conducive for progress in Yoga.
While preparing the personal cocktail, there are two important
points that need to be kept in mind. Firstly,
each individual needs to find his/her own recipe. Yoga is a very subjective pursuit and any kind of generalisation
does not work in this domain. So, neither should one try to copy another
person’s recipe nor try to impose his/her recipe on others. However, mutual
discussion to learn from each other’s experience is certainly welcome and very
useful. Secondly, one should not look
down upon any of these four paths. It is natural for different people to have
differential preference for these paths. But one should realise that each path has its own advantages and can
be very helpful if used judiciously. In order to succeed in any pursuit, there
are three essential ingredients: a clear idea about our strengths and weaknesses, a clear sense of direction, and an understanding of the likely challenges along this chosen
direction. The same holds for Yoga too!
The first step in preparing the Yoga cocktail is to carefully
analyze our strengths and weaknesses with respect to the four paths. How good
is our control over our emotions? How good is our intellectual ability to
understand a wide variety of concepts? How good are we at serving others
without expecting any return? How good are we at following a strict regime?
Here, it is again important to note that not being good at one of these
abilities is not necessarily a hindrance to our progress. In the realm of
Prakriti, no one is perfect, not even an Avatar. It is just that a good
awareness of our strengths and weaknesses will help in preparing the right
personal cocktail. Bhishma Pitamah was predominantly a Karma Yogi, Swami Vivekananda
was predominantly a Jnani, Meera Bai was predominantly a Bhakta and Sadhguru
Jaggi Vasudev is predominantly a Kriya Yogi. Each of these four and other
enlightened beings have their own strengths and weaknesses (at least as long
they remain in the realm of Prakriti).
The second step is to carefully choose the kind of experiences we
are interested in having during the spiritual process. Though these four paths
are said to lead to the same final goal, the experience we will have on the
path is likely to be quite varied. For example, a Jnani will develop a better
intellectual understanding of the world around, a Bhakta will develop a deep
emotional bond with his/her chosen form of God, a Karma Yogi will develop a
healthy relationship with the society, and a Kriya Yogi will experience
fantastic mental states. Though all these experiences may allure an aspirant,
it is important to note that the same person cannot have all these various
experiences with the same intensity. One has to choose.
The third important step is to understand the challenges faced while
pursuing each of these paths, and which ones are more aligned with our core
strengths. All spiritual aspirants face a certain kind of dryness at times on
their path, but the nature of dryness considerably varies depending on the
particular path. A Jnani may go through long periods of intellectual
stagnation, and a Bhakta may go through emotional frustration as a result of
unfulfilled longing. A Jnani may not be able to handle emotional frustration as
much as a Bhakta, and vice-versa. A Kriya Yogi may have to go through traumatic
occult experiences, which others may not be able to handle. And a Karma Yogi
may have to face insult even from people whom s/he serves, which might be a
nerve wrecking experience. There are many other challenges that one has to face
on each path, and an appreciation for these with respect for one’s strengths
and weaknesses is very helpful.
We might think that the easiest way to figure out the appropriate
path for us would be to find an enlightened being and surrender ourselves at
their feet. But this option is quite problematic for various reasons. Firstly, there is no objective way of
knowing that a particular person is enlightened. Even Vivekananda took many
years to convince himself that Ramakrishna had truly experienced Samadhi. Secondly, even if our chosen Guru is
enlightened, s/he may not be the right guide for us. Enlightenment beings come
in as many flavors as aspirants. Hanuman was a devotee of Rama and Arjuna of
Krishna. It is hard to imagine them exchanging their positions, even though we
may consider Rama and Krishna to be Avatar of the same Vishnu. Thirdly, in today’s world, most
spiritual Gurus run professional organizations with huge mass following and may
not have the time to design the path for individuals. There is nothing wrong in
learning a few tricks from them, but giving up our personal judgment for their
commandments is not very helpful. Their main purpose is to create a mass
movement, and not necessarily to lead individuals to final emancipation.
As mentioned earlier, there is no simple formula or recipe available
which can help us in finding the path most favourable to us. Also, even if we
find a recipe at a certain time, it is unlikely to last for a very long time.
This is because we go through several transformations as we make spiritual
progress, which changes our strengths, weaknesses and overall perceptions. This
requires a re-evaluation of the path we have chosen at regular intervals. This
is also one of the main reasons why people who seem to be making good progress
at one point of time suddenly start lagging behind. They simply fail to recognise
that things have changed and their cocktail also needs to be changed
accordingly. This is an important lesson for all of us. The more aware we are
of the above points, the better our progress is likely to be.
In today’s scenario, one of the best places to learn Karma, Bhakti and
Jnana Yoga is Sri Ramakrishna Mission. Isha Foundation is one of the best for
learning Kriya and Bhakti Yoga. Baba Ramdev also has some very nice online
lessons on Kriya Yoga. There are also several other organisations like the Gita
Press and Bihar School of Yoga, whose books contain a huge wealth of
information. It is very helpful to be
associated with several good organisations and learn from their experience. As
the popular Rig Vedic verse says, “Let
noble thoughts come to me from all directions”.
Comment :
ReplyDeleteIt is interesting that you talk about a "personal yoga cocktail". I see it as a weighted sum of the four yoga paths - Karma, Jnana, Bhakti and Raja (Kriya), with the weights decided by each individual according to his/her predilection. However, many consider the Raja yoga path (also known as the Astanga Yoga of Patanjali) to be most effective, and therefore, may be given the highest weight. A meditating (Raja) yogi is able to obtain knowledge of the Truth through intuition, rather than sensory perception or inference, which are considered to have their limitations as instruments of attaining knowledge.
Response:
Raja Yoga is precisely what is also called as Kriya Yoga, which is a term I prefer to use. Also please note that Ashtanga Yoga of Patanjali is a general principle and applicable to all the four paths. Of course, some people prefer Kriya Yoga over other paths for the reasons you have stated, and that is perfectly acceptable. The only important thing to understand is that what works for one may not work for others.
Comment:
ReplyDeleteVery interesting read, especially for those who think that the four paths are compartmentalized. However, I would just like to add a few more organizations to the last paragraph which in my expereince are worth connecting to, especially for the young: Arsha Vidya Gurukulam, Chinmaya Mission, Ramana Ashram, Art of Living, Kanchi Peetham. Many of them also have great pool of online content, set of workshops and camps, as well as books to read. :)
Comment:
ReplyDeleteSwami Chinmayanandaji's comment about running away from groups at a certain stage might be pertinent! Sadhana is very individual, can change directions and paths over time.
"The ideas we gather from books, contains, along with the grain, a lot of chaffs. To winnow it all and separate the grains from the chaff is “discussion”. The ideas gained in independent study must be brought out in the open and discussed. In the breeze of discussions, in the wind of arguments the chaff gets blown off and the true teachings, in their clear depths, become evident. This is discriminative knowledge. Having gained it, run away from groups!! Apply them in your life and realize the State of Truth in yourself. Om. Om. Om."
Life is multifaceted and multidimensional. One has to look at it from different perspectives and angles and live it accordingly. Reality manifests itself but one has to dwell deeper to understand the rhythms. Is that what you mean by cocktail ? Bitter and enjoyable experiences probably continue throughout or may be your approach towards them evolves.
ReplyDeleteYes, that is another nice way of describing the cocktail. Thanks! :)
DeleteComment:
ReplyDeleteNice. I would add to your last para, Satipatthana Sutta and Buddha's discourses. Website: https://accesstoinsight.org/ptf/dhamma/index.html